Examining
Diversity
A project completed in partial fulfillment of the requirements for Health Education 471
Southern Illinois University
Course Instructor: Judy C. Drolet, Ph.D.
Examining
Race
Examining Race in the Classroom
Many persons of color will attest to the high level of stress in the college classroom. They are expected to view the world through someone else's experience, often times being forced to negate their own. In addition, racial stereotypes prove to be a barrier to the learning process. Many times these stereotypes create an environment in which the persons of color are shut out of the learning process and the majority fails to appreciate the extent to which it has lost a vital, rich part of a discussion.
Race in the classroom is an important issue. If not dealt with at the onset of a term, the issues that do arise can become stressors to those of color in a classroom. This chapter examines race in the classroom and suggests three activities that can be used to promote the positive dimension to racial diversity within the classroom. For the purposes of this chapter, racial diversity is defined as the inclusion of students in a classroom that are American citizens with the following ethnic backgrounds: African American, Hispanic, Native American, Asian/Pacific Islander, or Alaskan Native.
Activity I: The Hunt for Skills
The following grids may be used as a diversity activity in any classroom. It allows the students to get to know one another, while at the same time enabling the instructor of the course to familiarize him/herself with the varied experiences of the group.
Procedure:
Has read at least three Shakespearean plays
|
Is a good editor |
Has had a linguistics course |
Understands Edgar Alan Poe poetry
|
This list of skills can be adapted for any course.
Activity II: Interviews
The purpose of this activity is to demonstrate to students that each student's perspective is not only unique but also a vital part of a discussion of almost any topic. The form may be adapted for use with any course. This activity ought to be completed prior to a discussion over the chosen topic. Be sure that the questions chosen are broad and open ended. Because this activity is designed to be racially based it is important that the students are encouraged to interview persons of an ethnic background different than their own.
The interview questions ought to reflect the course topic. There should be no more than ten questions, and the student ought to be given at least four weeks to complete this assignment. This is definitely an activity that must be included on the syllabus.
(What follows is a sample of questions developed for an English class)
Person Interviewed:_____________________________________________________
Do you believe there is a lack of diversity in the textbook? What impact might this have on the text.
__________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________
Do you feel that the inclusion of non-Caucasian authors in the text books should be required for [fill in the course title]
__________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________
Activity III: Class Favorites
This activity was adapted from Worksheet 6 in
Personal and Social Skills: Understanding and Integrating Competencies Across Health
Content,
by Dr. Joyce Fetro.
Procedure:
**This activity is also an ideal icebreaker. It is a great "getting to know you" tool at the beginning of a term. **
The following example is for a philosophy class.
Favorite Modern philosopher
|
Favorite Logic Principle |
Favorite Theorem
|
Favorite Kantian Construct |
Examining
Multiple
Cultures
Examining Multiple Cultures in the Classroom
Samovar and Porter define culture as: "the deposit of knowledge, experience, beliefs, values, attitudes, meanings, hierarchies, religion, notions of time, roles, spatial relations, concepts of the universe and material objects and possessions acquired by a group of people in the course of generations through individual and group striving" (p.11).
Given this very broad definition of culture, the importance of intercultural communication has clear value to us as citizens of the world. "Intercultural Communication occurs whenever a message produced in one culture must be processed in another culture." (Porter and Samovar, p. 7). At the tail end of this millennium, the human race is having to redefine itself. In the face of the tremendous influence of different forces of change, all previous understandings of boundaries, physical and intellectual, need revision. This includes the invasion of electronic media and transportation technologies across the world. The world is no longer the place it used to be, even ten years ago. Scores of people travel, emigrate, and move to different parts of the world each day. The United States has also seen a heavy traffic of immigrants for nearly 700 years. A strong delegation of immigrants manifests itself at first as international or foreign students at universities in the United States. SIUC ranked among the top few universities in the US only a few years ago in international student enrollment and continues to admit students from nearly 186 countries of the world.
International students bring with them sets of issues unique to their populations. Problems of a communicative nature occur almost inevitably for them and have begun to be addressed in a manner unprecedented. The following activities are designed to be conducted in the classroom. The activities compel the participants to immerse themselves briefly in "other" cultures and see themselves as others might.
Activity I: The Nacirema People
The purpose of this activity is to acquaint students with a "sense of culture" that is new and different from their usual. By doing this exercise they will gain insight into what international students come up against when they arrive to study in the United States.
Procedure:
You are visiting a foreign land called Nacirema. Its people practice some customs with which you are unfamiliar. Indicate your reactions in the following manner:
Write a 1 if you feel this practice should be abolished.
Write a 2 if you feel this practice should be changed.
Write a 3 if you feel this practice should be left as it is.
A. The Shrine:
B. The Latipost:
C. The Talking Tree:
D. The Sacred Rac:
Evaluation:
The symbols in this exercise are thinly veiled. The Shrine is the typical Medicine Box or Cabinet found in every American home, the Latipost is a hospital, the Talking Tree is the television and the Rac is the Car. These are objects of value in American society. Here is an opportunity to view them from the "outside" and if students are able to suspend their disbelief for the duration of the exercise, they could learn a little about themselves, how others see them, and how they often tend to look at peoples of other cultures.
Activity II: Intercultural Readiness Profile Test
Procedure: Fill out this profile and find out how ready you are to cope with new experiences that are confusing, unpredictable, frustrating, and even maddening. Read the following questions, and answer each one as you honestly believe you would react. Choose only one answer for each question. The score for each answer will be given after you complete the exercise.
Situation 1:![]() | In a foreign port, you are a passenger on a bus crowded with many people. You have to get off at the next stop. You signal the bus driver, and he slows the bus down but doesn't stop. You jump off while the bus is still moving past your stop. |
![]() | Your Chinese friend invites you to his home to meet the rest of the family. Another guest, an elderly Chinese man, arrives at the same time as you. You both enter the room where the family is waiting. The other guest greets the grandfather, then the father, and finally the son (your friend). It is now your turn to introduce yourself. |
![]() | You (an American) are in Athens and need to change some dollars to drachmae. You enter a store and show a $ 20.00 bill to the cashier and she jerks her head up and down as if to say "OK." You hand her the twenty. She looks puzzled and hands the money back. |
![]() | You are at a bar in a foreign city. At one point, you need to use the restroom. You ask a bartender to tell you where it is. He points to the exit. You walk outside and find no restroom, only the wall of the building. A number of men and some women are using the wall as a toilet. |
![]() | You are visiting your company's branch in Madrid, Spain for three months. You have invited your Spanish colleague and his family to your apartment for supper. The food is prepared and ready by 7:00 p.m., but your guests don't arrive until 9:00. Your food is soggy, burned and quite tasteless by now. |
When you're straight . . . |
When you're lesbian or gay . . . |
You get looks of admiration when you hold your partner's hand |
You get spat upon and jeered at when you hold your partner's hand |
You get a tax break for being married |
You can't GET married |
You have a life |
You have a "lifestyle" |
Standing up for your rights makes you a participatory citizen |
Standing up for your rights makes you a "militant homosexual". |
For the straight folks who dont mind gays but wish they werent so blatant
By Pat Parker
You know some people
got a lot of nerve
sometimes, I don't believe the things I see and hear.
Have you met the woman
who's shocked by two women kissing
and in the same breath,
tells you that she's pregnant?
BUT GAYS SHOULDN'T BE BLATANT.
Or this straight couple
sits next to you in a movie
and you can't hear the dialogue
Cause of the sound effects.
BUT GAYS SHOULDN'T BE SO BLATANT.
And the woman in your office
spends your entire lunch hour
talking about her new bikini drawers
and how much her husband likes them.
BUT GAYS SHOULDN'T BE BLATANT
Or the "hip" chick in your class,
rattling a mile a minute-
while you're trying to get stoned in the john,
about the camping trip she took with her musician boyfriend.
BUT GAYS SHOULDN'T BE BLATANT.
Or you go to an amusement park
and there's a tunnel of love
and pictures of straights painted on the front
and grinning couples coming in and out .
BUT GAYS SHOULDN'T BE BLATANT.
Fact is, blatant heterosexuals are all over the place.
Supermarkets, movies, on you job, in church, in books, on television
every day and night, every place-even in the gay bars.
And they want gay men and women to go hide in the closets
So to you straight folks, I say-Sure, I'll go if you go too,
but I'm polite, so, after you.
Examining
Gender
Examining Gender in the Classroom
Activity I: Showing Our Feelings
The goal of this activity is to demonstrate how members of different genders are socialized into expressing or suppressing certain emotions. Use the following procedures:
1. Provide the questionnaire to students and compare answers at the end.
2. Discuss why there might be differences between males and females.
3a. Discuss how this will impact them in relationships. Use a setting in your field.
OR
3b. Discuss how differences might affect the completion of work required in your class.
4. Discuss how students might help themselves or others to work with these differences.
Displaying Your Emotions |
Watching Others Emotions |
|
1. very frequently |
1. very comfortable |
|
2. frequently |
2. comfortable |
|
3. occasionally |
3. somewhat comfortable |
|
4. not very often |
4. not very comfortable |
|
5. rarely |
5. uncomfortable |
|
6. never |
6. very uncomfortable |
|
|
angry |
|
|
loving |
|
|
concerned |
|
|
anxious |
|
|
confident |
|
|
sad |
|
|
depressed |
|
|
jealous |
|
|
insecure |
|
|
silly |
|
|
violent |
|
|
argumentative |
|
|
proud |
|
|
friendly |
|
|
playful |
|
|
envious |
|
|
belligerent |
|
|
flirtatious |
|
|
hostile |
|
|
guilty |
|
|
unsure |
|
|
impatient |
|
|
arrogant |
|
Activity II: He Said, She Said
The goal of this activity is to start a dialogue between genders with the intention of demystifying some aspects of gender differences. The following procedures apply:
Divide the group into two sub-groups, males and females. Ask the females to make a list of questions theyve always wanted to ask the males, and have the males do the same for the females. Exchange the questions, and let the groups give answers.
Adaptation: This activity can be occupation and/or topic specific. Perhaps questions could be directly related to why they entered that degree program and the stereotypes that follow their gender (i.e. for engineers, what stereotypes come with being male of female; for political science, same issue).
Activity III: Portrayal of gender in the media
The goal of this activity is to review the gender types portrayed in the media, and its impact on student interactions. The following procedures apply:
Bring in a series of pictures of men and women from different media types: magazines, television, movies, etc. Ask the group to give their impression of what they see. Have the students respond to the following questions:
Investigate the differences in responses for men and women. Also, have them discuss the differences in acceptability ( i.e. they would marry someone who looks like this, but wouldnt want a sister who looked like this).
Examining
Non-Traditional
Students
Examining Non-Traditional Students in the Classroom
Older students face a unique and oftentimes difficult set of circumstances while trying to complete a degree. For many, school includes juggling spouses, children, and full-time employment, in addition to attending classes and studying for exams. Southern Illinois University at Carbondale uses the following guidelines to define the Non-Traditional Student.
1. Entering higher education at an older age than the traditional, just out of high school, freshman.
2. Returning to higher education after having stopped out at least once.
3. Married, divorced, widowed, and/or a parent.
Activity I: Communicating With Older Students
Instruct students to list stereotypical views they have held or heard their friends say about non-traditional students, and vice-versa. Then pair a non-traditional student with a traditional student to have them discuss these views. Then have the students report back any information they received through their conversation to counteract those stereotypical views.
Activity II: The Changing Face of the Classroom
Recently, the news has covered an issue concerning the great number of non-traditional students returning or entering college. An article entitled "Students 40 and over enroll at record level." Some of the main points of the article were:
Enrollment of students aged 40 and over more than tripled between 1970 and 1993, from 5.5% of students in 1970, to 11.2% in 1993. Some on the primary reasons given for this jump include, waning job skills (i.e., skills dont match the needs of todays workplace), a desire to enhance careers, a need to keep up with information and industry technology changes, and to satisfy changing lifestyles. Also, the article pointed out that 79% of non-traditional students are enrolled part-time, with 57% working at least 30 hours per week. The typical 40-plus student is white, female, and married. Non-traditional students tend to have better grades than younger students.
Consider the following questions with the class:
Encourage non-traditional students to discuss their college experience. For traditional students, ask how having non-traditional students in class has helped (experiences, decision making, etc.).
Assign the students to groups to discuss and share their answers to these questions. When possible, combine non-traditional and traditional students in the groups.